As the Country begins to emerge from destructive recession, many small and medium sized enterprises are continuing to struggle to survive in circumstances where historical debt and pre-recession contracts (e.g. inappropriate upward only rent reviews, unaffordable rents, etc.) place an unsustainable burden on the company’s business. While an embattled company may very well be a viable business and, indeed, may otherwise have a positive future in the brightening economic environment, these debts and legacy issues act to prevent the resurgence of the company’s business.
As a result of the hangover of the recent boom and crash the fear is that, in the absence of suitable intervention, well managed Irish companies with good businesses will continue to fail in the years to come. If a company has a good business but is failing to thrive by reason of historical debt or legacy contracts, Examinership (and indeed Examinership lite) may well be the most suitable option to save the company.
Examinership is a process where the Court provides protection and oversight to a petitioning company to allow it, with the assistance of the appointed Examiner, to explore all options to save the company’s business so that it might thrive into the future. To date, the Examinership process has been underused by Irish companies.
There was a perception that Examinership was a prohibitively expensive High Court process reserved for large companies. While it is certainly the case that many high profile large companies have entered Examinership in recent years, Clarke Jeffers has successfully assisted several enterprises from the SME market through the High Court Examinership process.
On 24th December 2013, the President signed into law the Companies (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act, 2013 which provides for Examinership in the Circuit Court. This new departure has become known as “Examinership Lite”. It is hoped that this extension of jurisdiction will encourage insolvent small and medium sized companies whose core business remains viable to seek the protection and assistance of the Court by way of Examinership. It has been our experience that the High Court has been very supportive of suitable SME companies entering Examinership; we expect this sympathetic and encouraging attitude will be mirrored in proceedings in the Circuit Court under Examinership Lite.
A small and medium sized enterprise will be allowed to bring their Examinership application in the Circuit Court jurisdiction if it meets at least two of the following three conditions.
- The company’s balance sheet is less than €4.4 million.
- Turnover at the company is less than €8.8 million.
- The company has less than 50 employees.
In Examinership, Court protection is granted for an initial period of seventy days (which can be then extended by a further thirty days at the Courts discretion). During this time creditors (i.e. trade creditors, lending institutions, landlords, hire purchase and leasing companies, Revenue etc.) are prevented from enforcing debts against the company; a liquidator or receivers cannot be appointed to the company and no winding-up proceedings may be taken. Effectively the court’s protective shield provides “breathing space” to allow the Examiner, working with the company’s management, time to assess the position and to set about designing a scheme of arrangement with creditors which may involve the writing down of debt, the disclaimer of onerous leases or contracts, etc.
Under the process, management of the company remain in control. The Examiner assists the company through the Examinership process and, ultimately, his role is to try and formulate a scheme of arrangement to allow the company to survive and thrive into the future. At the heart of the process is the desire to save good businesses and the jobs they provide in the community. The process favours consensual “deals” with classes of creditors; however, if at the conclusion of the process, the Court forms the view that the Examiner’s scheme of arrangement is fair and that it provides a reasonable basis for the survival of the company, it may impose the terms of the scheme of arrangement on objecting creditors.
Clarke Jeffers & Co can advise on all aspects of corporate restructuring and advice on the options open to and suitable for you and your business.
Get In Touch
What Our Clients Say
Clarke Jeffers & Co provide Costa Coffee Ireland with bespoke property and conveyancing advice. They understand Costa’s business and requirements and they offer sound legal advice with an excellent knowledge of the retail property market and the general business climate, Clarke Jeffers add value
Director, Costa Coffee Ireland
Introducing a new franchise into the country gets a whole lot easier when you hire a firm who know exactly what they are doing. Clarke Jeffers excelled in their industry knowledge and insight.
Michael Kelly, CEO Saladbox Ireland
As an Irish international rugby player I am used to having people I can rely on, both on the pitch and off. Clarke Jeffers to me is a safe pair of hands whose integrity cannot be questioned. They provide me with advice I can trust. That to me is what is important.
Gordon Darcy, Rugby International, Leinster & Ireland
Over the past number years our Company has used Clarke Jeffers Solicitors to handle our business needs. When dealing with matters on our behalf we have always been delighted to know that Clarke Jeffers is acting for us and they have clearly demonstrated a principle of “pro-activity” rather than “reactivity”. The turnaround of paperwork is swift and sure footed and their engaging and unflappable manner when dealing with difficult issues has only helped us grow as a company.
Giles Lloyd, Director
The Irish Pony Club has for several generations enjoyed the comfort of the professional services of Clarke Jeffers & Co. Solicitors, Carlow. We very much look forward to the continuation of this association into the future.
Chairman & Director, I.P.C
P&A Insolvency Services is a market leader in the provision of insolvency services in Ireland. We demand that all our professionals have the highest form of expertise and experience in the commercial sector. We have employed Clarke Jeffers & Co. in Liquidations, Company restructures and Examinerships. Their knowledge of the sector and expertise in insolvency matters is hugely impressive. Most impressive however is their ability to turn problems into solutions. Victor and his team are an easy choice for us.
Jason Sheehy, Director
Victor and his team are fantastically reliable to deal with. They “get” commercial contracts and understand the need to be practical. Without question they are serious operators.
Glenda Gilson, Model & TV Presenter
Clarke Jeffers provide solutions to complicated commercial issues for our clients on a weekly basis. Their knowledge of the tightly regulated pensions sector is exceptional and the ease at which they go about their business is very impressive.
Andrew O’Loughlin, Managing Director
When it comes to food and beverage we have a one stop shop in Clarke Jeffers. They know the industry, they know what’s required and most importantly, they know how to provide it quickly. For a luxury hotel and golf resort, that is priceless.
Aidan O’Sullivan, General Manager
We have been with Clarke Jeffers for many years now. They have a great attitude. Dare I say very commercial and not typically Solicitor like. They always exceed what we expect.
Erik Holstein, Managing Director
12 acres brewing retains the services of Victor Clarke of Clarke Jeffers & Co Solicitors for commercial legal advice. We find his advice clear thinking and very practical.
Paddy McDonald, Director
Codd Mushrooms is a large horticultural company based in Carlow. We have been clients of Clarke Jeffers for many years, and we have a very good working relationship with Victor, William and their team. Their knowledge of our industry, and the professional manner that they conduct business is exemplary. Their ‘can do attitude’ to difficult business situations is certainly a breath of fresh air.
Leslie Codd, CEO
We need a firm of lawyers that know how to help us expand our business. They need to have in-depth industry knowledge and understand how a modern food and beverage business works in the real world. Clarke Jeffers fit this brief perfectly. Simply put we trust them not only to keep up with our business but to keep it right.
Serghei Jolondcovschi, Director CSJ Master t/a Domino’s Pizza
Clarke Jeffers provide us with insightful and practical advice that we feel adds value to our business. Their understanding and knowledge of the fast food industry is top class.
MBBC Foods (Ireland) Ltd
I found Victor and Staff very professional to deal with but in a friendly and relaxed fashion, the advice and confidence I gained from this team was second to none and I am very grateful to all at Clarke Jeffers for their help over the past 12 months. I would recommend them without hesitation for all aspects of Legal Advice.
Marcus McCormack, Managing Director
We’ve worked closely with Clarke Jeffers over the last 8 years and I cannot recommend their services highly enough. We’ve always found their staff to be highly professional, responsive and they have helped us resolve issues quickly.
Michele Neylon, Managing Director
Victor has an excellent understanding of the business of franchising, I found his advice invaluable when I was starting my own business and negotiating my contract, I would have no hesitation in recommending Clarke Jeffers for sound business and legal advice’.
Paddy McDonald, Managing Director
As Ireland’s largest chain of fitness clubs and a key player in the Irish franchising sector, we have been involved in numerous commercial transactions, negotiations and of course the odd conflict along the way! Victor and the team at Clarke Jeffers has been an invaluable asset to us on this journey. From when we started in 2005 with our first club and our first member to a membership today of over 25,000 in Ireland alone, Clarke Jeffers has been there every step of the way.
John Hannaford, Director
We have always been very happy with the representation and advice from Clarke Jeffers. Firstly they are proactive and on the ball, secondly they have a “what we can do as opposed to what we can’t do approach. They possess the type of forward thinking that a progressive business such as ours demands.
We have worked with Clarke Jeffers & Co solicitors for many years. They have consistently given us clear and easy to understand advice. Most importantly, they have give us effective advice. A very professional outfit.
Patrick O’Toole, Director
Clarke Jeffers understand our business. The speed and accuracy of their responses to our needs is testament to their awareness of the commercial issues we face. We have absolute confidence in their ability to advise us on an ongoing basis.
Paddy Kavanagh, Managing Director
Stay In The Legal Loop — 'The Firm' Podcast
At Clarke Jeffers we place importance on providing commentary on topical issues and providing useful legal information, hints and tips when we can. Through our blog and Podcast series ‘The Firm’ we offer you unique and interesting insights into the Irish legal sector which could benefit you in a personal and professional light.
Gary Flannery: Breaking 10View in iTunes
Inward Investment in IrelandView in iTunes
From Rudolph’s red nose to Ashley MadisonView in iTunes
Cyber Crime. The modern day boogiemanView in iTunes
Franchising. Quick buck or hard slog? What you need to knowView in iTunes
Should I stay or should I go now?View in iTunes
The Companies Act 2014View in iTunes
Arrange A Callback